• 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 7
 
User avatar
Oppai
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 111
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 3:06 pm
Location: Sri Lanka

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 4:50 pm

People should stop complaining about p2w etc etc.
Its not your game.
If you feel its p2w then by all means dont play the game.
Making a rant about it and comparing it to so and so x other games doesn't really matter. This is Valiant force and not those games.
If you want other games system then go play those other games.

The paying aspect of the game was already discussed and the admins/dev gave a reasonable response. there is no point bringing it up multiple times.
 
User avatar
Hanzo
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 4:42 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 4:51 pm

It's nice to see other player's point of view and their defence of the game mechanics. Let's set the topic straight here : This topic is not about F2P vs P2W. I might have gotten on the wrong footing and I apologies. This topic is about having to pay too much. F2P players may never compete with P2W players,  that is a fact but even among P2W players, the playing field is far too uneven. How much do you have to spend on the game to be the very best?

I consider myself a P2W gamer but I'm not a whale, maybe a dolphin. I've played mobile P2W games all the way back from Blood Brothers, Tower of Saviors, Brave Frontier to the more recent games like Final Fantasy Brave Exvius. I've even dabbled my toes into weeb games like Kancolle and Fate but never have I encountered a P2W game of this scale.

I've never played 7 Knights but do they have the same number of P2W mechanics as Valiant Force? Yes, Limit Break is also in 7 Knight but they also have something similar to other cash grabs like Faith and gacha equipment?

In a game like this, you would never be able to be the best in Arena unless you can afford to fork out thousand of dollars cause clearly the game is saying if you can't afford to pay, stay out of the Arena.
At the very least, there are no god-tier items which are locked and reserved for cash players, that is the first thing I asked before I pre-registered for VF.

Is there a mobile game where F2P players are just a tiny few steps behind whales?

The admin said they researched on the most popular recent games, I am guessing 7K is one of the few.
That's the thing, lv35 Valiant Units are effectively locked and reserved for whales because of how difficult it is to get 6 identical rare units. F2P players will never get a lv 35 because they would have to play for literally decades to get 6 identical rare units.   The common excuse is that "Hey, we give out free crystals, F2P can get anything a P2P player can get, just slower." Well, how much slower because if it's gonna take decades then that's not really reasonable.

I like this game, I really do and I don't mind paying for it. But what I don't want is to know that even if I spend hundreds on this game every month, I will never be on an even playing field with someone who spends thousands. The power ceiling for this game is simply far too high and too expensive to reach.

For games like MMOs,  when you reach the max level, PVP becomes a matter of skill.

For Game of Dice, I spent $900, got the best character at the time,  I'm done. I can fight evenly with everyone else.

Brave Frontier, $1600, I got a full team of Kikuri. I got top 10 in the Arena.

How much do I have to spend in Valiant Knights?
The name of the game is Valiant Force.

And from what I know, Prestige 15 is just a few hundred dollars. And F2P will enjoy all the same content as those at Prestige 15.
 
User avatar
Jenoss
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 312
Joined: Mon Aug 29, 2016 5:36 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 4:57 pm

I have seen people,complaining about how P2W Hearthstone is as well, given that those who spend thousands on packs get the good cards immediately, whereas the F2P players have to spend much more time to grind and get them. I was a heavy whale in Hearthstone, FYI, and almost went to play competitive until I got super annoyed with the regular changes Blizz made to nerf cards.

Doesn't VF has the same system? 
In Hearthstone,  if you spend a measly $1000, even if you do not get the cards you want, you can break down junk cards into dust and get all the cards you want. This system does not exist in VF. Spend $1000 on VF and you might not even get 5 valiant.
VF is giving free gems and gold to aid the F2P players. Of course, everyone will complain the amount is not enough. They will only feel it is enough when they are on par with those who spend. 
Well, in comparison evento 7k, the gems they give are really really really few.
Anyway Heartstone have the 80% of the userbase happy about the game, and you can check in on their forums too!
Complain topics are really almost disappeared.

Anyway i'm a p2p player usually, and in my opinion the best way to get money to the company and make happy the userbase is make content for pay, and with content i means: 
Special missions, special new hero (not overpowered), special new content (raid boss / istances / put contents here)

And for that you can even put a monthly fee, to guarantee all players to be able to play everything with based amount of money (like on p2p mmorpgs)
Free to play players would be always competitive but have access to less content for free
With huge number of microtransitions, you just burn the userbase.
P2P players will get bored to pay for soo many single small things, and F2P player will need like months just to get a 5 star hero..
 
Levizt
Junior Member
Junior Member
Topic Author
Posts: 12
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2016 2:24 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 4:58 pm

At the very least, there are no god-tier items which are locked and reserved for cash players, that is the first thing I asked before I pre-registered for VF.

Is there a mobile game where F2P players are just a tiny few steps behind whales?

The admin said they researched on the most popular recent games, I am guessing 7K is one of the few.
That's the thing, lv35 Valiant Units are effectively locked and reserved for whales because of how difficult it is to get 6 identical rare units. F2P players will never get a lv 35 because they would have to play for literally decades to get 6 identical rare units.   The common excuse is that "Hey, we give out free crystals, F2P can get anything a P2P player can get, just slower." Well, how much slower because if it's gonna take decades then that's not really reasonable.

I like this game, I really do and I don't mind paying for it. But what I don't want is to know that even if I spend hundreds on this game every month, I will never be on an even playing field with someone who spends thousands. The power ceiling for this game is simply far too high and too expensive to reach.

For games like MMOs,  when you reach the max level, PVP becomes a matter of skill.

For Game of Dice, I spent $900, got the best character at the time,  I'm done. I can fight evenly with everyone else.

Brave Frontier, $1600, I got a full team of Kikuri. I got top 10 in the Arena.

How much do I have to spend in Valiant Knights?
The name of the game is Valiant Force.

And from what I know, Prestige 15 is just a few hundred dollars. And F2P will enjoy all the same content as those at Prestige 15.
I was making a snide remark since VF is being compared to 7 Knights so much. And again, F2P will never enjoy lv35 valiant.

I really like this game and comments like "if you don't like the p2w, then don't play" isn't helping this game. What I'm doing is giving my feedback in the hopes that the devs might take notice and change the system to make it more accessible for players, making the game more successful in the long run.
 
soggybear
Official Member
Official Member
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2016 8:30 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 4:59 pm

Hope that f2p players can clear all future/current content(events). Just because it's not locked doesn't mean you can clear it without 'paying'.

What TS pointed out is that this game have too much RNG aspect. Heroes, equipments (not just one equipment needed, but 6), faith system. What's the implication?
Basically you'll need to spend a hell lot of money in order to play at an even ground with the big spenders. The power difference between mid - high spenders will be too big imo.
Last edited by soggybear on Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:05 pm, edited 1 time in total.
 
User avatar
Hanzo
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 4:42 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:01 pm


In Hearthstone,  if you spend a measly $1000, even if you do not get the cards you want, you can break down junk cards into dust and get all the cards you want. This system does not exist in VF. Spend $1000 on VF and you might not even get 5 valiant.
VF is giving free gems and gold to aid the F2P players. Of course, everyone will complain the amount is not enough. They will only feel it is enough when they are on par with those who spend. 
Well, in comparison evento 7k, the gems they give are really really really few.
Anyway Heartstone have the 80% of the userbase happy about the game, and you can check in on their forums too!
Complain topics are really almost disappeared.

Anyway i'm a p2p player usually, and in my opinion the best way to get money to the company and make happy the userbase is make content for pay, and with content i means: 
Special missions, special new hero (not overpowered), special new content (raid boss / istances / put contents here)

And for that you can even put a monthly fee, to guarantee all players to be able to play everything with based amount of money (like on p2p mmorpgs)
Free to play players would be always competitive but have access to less content for free
With huge number of microtransitions, you just burn the userbase.
P2P players will get bored to pay for soo many single small things, and F2P player will need like months just to get a 5 star hero..
Admin already said there will not be special events or content only for Prestige players. Content will be open to all players. I think VF dev team is already taking a risk not to keep the whales happy and making them feel superior.

I have seen my F2P friend obtain Valiants from free rolls, and others who paid not getting any... So this is Free-to-Win? Lol. A full team of valiants can be brought down by a team of non-valiants easily if the aura is not right.

I still have no idea where the P2W element is other than gold and hero sinks. 
 
User avatar
Hanzo
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 4:42 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:02 pm

Hope that f2p players can clear all future/current content(events). Just because it's not locked doesn't mean you can clear it without 'paying'.

What TS pointed out is that this game have too much RNG aspect. Heroes, equipments (not just one equipment needed, but 6), faith system.
Admin already confirmed from previous "P2W" threads that no content or items will be locked or exclusive to prestige players.
 
soggybear
Official Member
Official Member
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Aug 27, 2016 8:30 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:08 pm

Hope that f2p players can clear all future/current content(events). Just because it's not locked doesn't mean you can clear it without 'paying'.

What TS pointed out is that this game have too much RNG aspect. Heroes, equipments (not just one equipment needed, but 6), faith system.
Admin already confirmed from previous "P2W" threads that no content or items will be locked or exclusive to prestige players.
Like I said, just because it's not locked or being exclusive to vip players, doesn't mean people can clear the content. Look at the lulu event lol.
 
Levizt
Junior Member
Junior Member
Topic Author
Posts: 12
Joined: Thu Sep 01, 2016 2:24 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:10 pm

I respect your dedication and passion for the game Hanzo but can you honestly say that a F2P player can get a lv35 valiant?
 
User avatar
Bunny
Valiant Sage
Valiant Sage
Posts: 374
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2016 2:42 pm

Re: Most P2W game ever? A study and objective comparison.

Thu Sep 01, 2016 5:10 pm

In this game even big spenders will have difficult time getting a max limit break valiant. There are 6 Valiants and getting the same one over and over will be quite hard.
And even having full team of Valiant doesn't guarantee a win in Arena.
It is similar to when Seven Knights was released, although 7k characters are so strong, normal character are much easy to limit break.
I played Seven Knights during release and the top arena teams are full of Level 40 normal characters.
In VF you even get a free Valiant at the start I don't remember Seven Knights giving me a 7K character during start.

I hope they add more features like Raid during launch so that people can get equipments through there as well.
And in many games they give big rewards for collecting a certain amount of "stars" in each mode, maybe they can consider doing that.
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 7